One of the problems with the lack of motivation is that students are forced to view what is important because we, teachers, tell them that it is important. I remember when I was in high school and we were forced to read Shakespeare and hating. It was not until I went to college and learned about the canon or should I say the Western canon of literature. Wikipedia states that the pieces of canon have been the most important and influential in shaping the Western culture. Or, as I was taught that the canon are novels that are timeless and be applied to any generation. Nowadays and even when I was in school, the school district would mandate that we teach specific books every semester for every grade level.
I think many students get frustrated because they cannot relate to the novels that are thrown at them. If we have to push these books on our students then at least we can give them alternatives outside the demanded readings. When I would at a native boarding school years ago, my students were reading Achenua Achebe's Things Fall Apart. The book incorporated a lot of proverbs to help simplify and as a display of culture. To help the students better relate to the incoming colonization (forgive me if I ruined the story) and their own experience, students were to bring in proverbs and folklore from their own tribes and culture and then interpret them for the class. This help to show the students that even a Nigerian tribe can have a lot in common with a Native American tribe.
Students also have a problem with required reading materials because of the simple questions: What does this have to with our lives now? This is why we must always bring in outside materials to help complement a novel. Too many of us lay out vocabulary, have students read the chapter and have them answer the questions. It is great to incorporate current events along with a section of the story to show them that what is happening in the story is also happening now.
Another reason that students are unmotivated with class readings is because we never take chances with our text. We, as educators are always playing it same because we do not want our students to be exposed to issues that they probably already have been exposed to. A lot of the problem is not that we are afraid to expose our students to issues that are relevant but many times, we have to get materials approved and proves to be a problem. I remember teaching To Kill a Mockingbird and then hearing a segment on NPR that was discussing the fact that Kansas banned the book due to the racism and the use of the “N” word. God forbid that I student realize that America had a racist past.
Yes, we need to make good use of novels and textbooks but we cannot expect them to teach the class for us. We need to always be ready to innovate and keep our student interested and stimulated. If not, we might as well go make to worksheets and regurgitation.

Omar- We need to supplement what our students are reading with real-life adult books. We do not spend our entire lives working in textsbooks. We read "adult" books. This may be more interesting than the textsbooks we demand our students read.
ReplyDeleteI love the picture and the title for this blog. I agree with you Omar we need to get kids involved in their education and want to participate. I also think that a lot of teachers take textbooks for granted. By attaining the answer to the questions in the textbook and even pre-made tests for that chapter.
ReplyDeleteOne of the biggest problems with literature class is that teachers do not discuss and unpack books with their students. Some of these controversial books can been great teaching tools to open our eyes to our past and to help us to become better people because of our understanding.
ReplyDeleteI also love the picture at the end of your post! I agree with what you said about students not being motivated about reading because they do not know how it can relate to their lives now. In high school I took a class called American studies and it was a history and an English class that was taught together. We would read a book in the english class that went along with what we where learning in our history class. This was great becuase it gave me some relevance on why what I was reading was important and how it related to part of my life.
ReplyDeleteI was one of those high school students who were very resistive and defiant when it came time to read Shakespeare and, in fact, I still am. But, when we got around to reading Homer or Dickens, I would easily become absorbed into reading. The book I'm reading now has a chapter that discusses how, as teachers, we may have to allow certain students to choose what books they want to read. Don't you think it is interesting that we, in this class, were allowed to choose the book we wanted to read?
ReplyDelete